David Cameron rudest UK prime minister in 40 yearsChristian Fernsby ▼ | July 5, 2019
Research analysing Prime Minister’s Questions (PMQs) over a period of nearly 40 years has revealed that David Cameron personally insulted the leader of the opposition more than any other prime minister.
Britain Prime Minister David Cameron
At this time almost 62% of his replies to leader of the opposition Ed Miliband contained a disrespectful comment.
However, Cameron’s attacks reduced significantly to just 20% towards the end of his time in office when responding to questions from Jeremy Corbyn.
The research suggests this may have partly been due to a new approach to PMQs introduced by Corbyn, which included questions to Cameron sourced from members of the public.
Established in the 18th century, PMQs form an important part of the democratic process by providing an opportunity to hold government to account.
However, in practice, the mud-slinging, point-scoring and evasive answers that have played out on TV since 1989 (and now across social media) have led to public frustration.
For the studies, the researchers devised a coding system to evaluate the levels of personally insulting language between the PM and the leader of the opposition in PMQs held between 1979 and 2016.
Transcripts of PMQs from this period, which covers the early and latter premiership periods of Thatcher, Major, Blair, Brown, and Cameron, were analysed.
The studies one looking at personal attacks during PMQs and the second examining the impact on personal attacks of Corbyn’s “public questions” approach only took into account comments that were personally disrespectful from the exchanges between the PM and the Leader of the Opposition.
The results of the study showed that Corbyn was one of the least disrespectful leaders of the opposition across the 37 year period and it is plausible that Cameron’s reduced aggression may have been a case of reciprocal politeness.
Towards the end of his premiership, the two politicians were also campaigning on the same side of the EU referendum debate and low poll ratings for Labour at that time may have prompted the view that personally attacking Corbyn across the dispatch box was not in the interests of the Tory party. ■